6.21.1.2 What are options for?
Options are used to provide extra information to tune or customize the
execution of a program. In case it wasn't clear, options are usually
optional. A program should be able to run just fine with no options
whatsoever. (Pick a random program from the Unix or GNU toolsets. Can
it run without any options at all and still make sense? The main
exceptions are find
, tar
, and dd
--all of which are mutant
oddballs that have been rightly criticized for their non-standard syntax
and confusing interfaces.)
Lots of people want their programs to have ``required options''. Think about it. If it's required, then it's not optional! If there is a piece of information that your program absolutely requires in order to run successfully, that's what positional arguments are for.
As an example of good command-line interface design, consider the humble
cp
utility, for copying files. It doesn't make much sense to try to
copy files without supplying a destination and at least one source.
Hence, cp
fails if you run it with no arguments. However, it has a
flexible, useful syntax that does not require any options at all:
cp SOURCE DEST cp SOURCE ... DEST-DIR
You can get pretty far with just that. Most cp
implementations
provide a bunch of options to tweak exactly how the files are copied:
you can preserve mode and modification time, avoid following symlinks,
ask before clobbering existing files, etc. But none of this distracts
from the core mission of cp
, which is to copy either one file to
another, or several files to another directory.
See About this document... for information on suggesting changes.